Claim Dependencies: [Book Title]
**Created:** [Date] **Last Updated:** [Date] **Version:** [e.g., v1, v2]
Overview
Claim Dependencies: [Book Title]
Created: [Date]
Last Updated: [Date]
Version: [e.g., v1, v2]
Purpose
Maps logical dependencies between claims. Some claims are foundational; others build on them. This reveals which claims are load-bearing and helps architect structure the argument.
Dependency Map
Foundational Claims (No Dependencies)
These claims stand on their own and support other claims:
| Claim # | Claim | Supports |
|---|---|---|
| [#] | [Claim] | [List of claim #s that depend on this] |
Dependent Claims
These claims require other claims to be established first:
| Claim # | Claim | Depends On | Strength of Dependency |
|---|---|---|---|
| [#] | [Claim] | [Claim #s] | [Essential / Supporting] |
Dependency Strength:
- Essential — If the foundation fails, this claim collapses
- Supporting — Foundation strengthens but isn't required
Dependency Chains
Sequences where claims build on each other:
Chain [#]: [Name/Theme]
[Claim #] → [Claim #] → [Claim #] → [Claim #]
↓
[Claim #]
Narrative: [Brief explanation of how these connect]
Chain [#]: [Name/Theme]
[Repeat structure]
Load-Bearing Analysis
Most Critical Claims:
Claims that, if they fail, cause multiple other claims to fall:
| Claim # | Claim | Claims That Fall If This Fails |
|---|---|---|
| [#] | [Claim] | [List] |
Implication for Validation:
[Which claims need the strongest evidence?]
Isolated Claims
Claims that don't depend on others and nothing depends on them:
| Claim # | Claim | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| [#] | [Claim] | [Could be cut without affecting argument?] |
Updated by idea-validator skill